Tuesday, August 4, 2015

Weekly Highlights: The Tyranny of Tier Two


 27 July - 2 August 2015
 Weekly Highlights

The Tyranny of Tier Two

On 27 July, the U.S. Department of State released the annual Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report for the year 2015. The report places countries around the world in one of four categories based on their commitment to enacting legislation and criminal penalties in regards to human trafficking, empowering law enforcement with the skills necessary to identify trafficking networks, and efforts to create protection services for trafficking victims. This year Burma was again given a "Tier 2" rating – which it has maintained since 2011 – implying that, "The Government of Burma does not fully comply with the minimum standards for the elimination of trafficking; however, it is making significant efforts to do so.

The decision to keep Burma out of Tier 3 status, along with the promotion of Malaysia to Tier 2, has drawn considerable criticism from a number of human rights organizations. According to Matthew Smith, Executive Director of Fortify Rights, "The decisions regarding Malaysia and Myanmar were largely political and don't reflect either country's record on human trafficking. This decision is a disservice to the many victims and survivors of human trafficking." Instead, critics believe Burma's promotion to be based on the reluctance of the U.S. and the international community to showcase the long-touted "emerging democracy" as anything but an astounding success.

According to the statement released by Fortify Rights, the TIP report largely ignored the contribution of the Burma Government to the systematic abuse of the Rohingya religious minority, which recently led to a spiraling out of control refugee crisis in the Andaman Sea. The massive exodus of Rohingya out of Burma towards countries like Thailand and Malaysia has created a significant population of individuals vulnerable to traffickers wishing to capitalize on their desperation for economic opportunities and a life free from abuse. It is, after all, the discriminatory policies of the Burma Government that have driven thousands of fleeing Rohingya to become enslaved in Thailand's notorious fishing industry.  In a separate statement, Smith noted that, "Myanmar and Thailand have been complicit in a deadly trade in Rohingya asylum seekers that has generated up to $250 million dollars for transnational criminal syndicates since 2012."

Internal human trafficking is also readily apparent in a number of Burma's ethnic areas. The Burma Army has been known to use the forced labor of Rohingya, including that of children, despite a promise from President Thein Sein that the practice would be eliminated during the reform period. Child Soldiers International has also compiled disturbing information on the use of child soldiers through two separate reports this year. The first report, from January 2015, highlights the repeated and widespread recruitment of children by the Burma Army, occasionally involving intimidation or coercion.  A subsequent report in July 2015 also indicated that the practice of recruiting child soldiers was pervasive among armed ethnic groups, in this case, the Kachin Independence Army.

Dr. Saw Ivan, operations director at World Vision Myanmar, spoke with Channel News Asia of the opportunities for greater labor exploitation that will inevitably come along with Burma's recent economic expansion. In reference to rural populations, he stated, "When you come from the villages, if you ... don't understand the labor law, if you don't understand the trafficking, your rights, any time you can be exploited."

Sex trafficking of women, especially amongst vulnerable ethnic groups displaced as a result of conflict and extreme poverty, has also been widely reported along the Kachin-China border. China's Yunnan, in particular, has maintained its status as a historical hub for forced marriages and bride trafficking primarily from Kachin State.

Despite how widespread human trafficking has become for Burma, there appears to be little accomplished towards finding a solution to the problem. The Myanmar Times has pointed out that the TIP report mentions a severely limited number of prosecutions and reporting on trafficking cases, despite evidence that these cases are occurring frequently. Also worth mentioning is the absence of cases in Arakan State, which is worrisome considering the extent of the abuse facing the religious minority in the region.

As a signatory of the United Nation's Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, Burma is expected to demonstrate a commitment to addressing the problem of human trafficking. However, considering the pervasiveness of human trafficking in Burma – both internal and as a source country for neighboring countries – it is clear that the efforts of the Burma Government to combat the issue are either ineffective or non-existent. Unfortunately, as a Tier 2 country in the 2015 TIP report, Burma has escaped much of the international pressure, in the form of sanctions that are required to motivate the government to better address this problem.

The international community must ensure that human rights, especially for victims of trafficking, are prioritized over competing political or economic interests. The root causes of trafficking in Burma, including the vulnerability of ethnic groups as a result of state sponsored discrimination, must be addressed in all legislation surrounding human trafficking in the country.

The international community must ensure that human rights, especially for victims of trafficking, are prioritized over competing political or economic interests. The root causes of trafficking in Burma, including the vulnerability of ethnic groups as a result of state sponsored discrimination, must be addressed in all legislation surrounding human trafficking in the country.


Latest from the Blog

The Release of all Human Rights Defenders and Political Prisoners is a Benchmark for Free and Fair Elections
By Burma Partnership


In Rakhine State, the Arakan National Party is calling on the Burma Government to provide urgent needs for those affected by floods and is also calling for international humanitarian organizations to cooperate with the Burma government in order to facilitate rescue operations

Out of the 18 students who signed a complaint letter, 13 students met with Myanmar National Human Rights Commission (MNHRC); some of their fellow signatories were unable to attend the meeting due to current outstanding arrest warrants and the jailing of one student. In addition, In response to a complaint from the Myanmar Lawyer's Network, the MNHRC stated that three of their members had in fact attended the Tharrawaddy Prison to conduct interviews with prison staff, detained students, and their supporters, but the MNHRC's report largely downplays the allegations leveled against prison authorities and therefore lawyers expressed dissatisfaction with its findings
and lawyer Robert San Aung who represents students jailed in Letpadan submits a case against two officers who were involved in the brutal crackdown for wrongly detaining students

Statements and Press Releases

Presidential Amnesty does little to Liberate Burma's Political Prisoners

By The Assistance Association for Political Prisoners and Former Political Prisoners Society

ရခုိင္ျပည္၏ လက္ရွိသဘာ၀ေဘးအႏၱရာယ္က်ေရာက္ေနမႈအေျခအေနအေပၚ ရခုိင္ျပည္လုံးဆုိင္ရာေက်ာင္းသားႏွင့္လူငယ္မ်ားအစည္းအ႐ုံး (AASYC) မွ ထုုတ္ျပန္ေၾကညာခ်က္

By All Arakan Students' and Youths' Congress

Myanmar: Prisoners of Conscience Released in Amnesty but Scores Remain Behind Bars

By Amnesty International

Political Prisoner Releases Welcome but also Highlights Return to Than Shwe Approach

By Burma Campaign UK

လက္ရွိျဖစ္ေပၚေနေသာ ျမန္မာႏိုင္ငံတြင္းေရေဘးအႏၱရာယ္ႏွင့္ပတ္သက္၍ အရပ္ဖက္လထုအဖဲြ႔အစည္းမ်ား၏ ထုတ္ျပန္ေၾကညာခ်က္

By Civil Society Forum

Five Myanmar Journalists Freed from Prison as Part of Mass Amnesty

By The Committee to Protect Journalists

Foreign Office Minister Hugo Swire Visits Burma's Rakhine State

By Foreign & Commonwealth Office and The Rt Hon Hugo Swire MP

US: Don't Let Trade Trump Human Rights

By Fortify Rights

SD ႏွင့္ UPWC တုိ႔၏ တစ္ႏုိင္ငံလုံးအပစ္အခတ္ရပ္စဲေရးဆုိင္ရာ သေဘာတူစာခ်ဳပ္(မူၾကမ္း) (၈)ႀကိမ္ေျမာက္ညွိႏႈိင္းေဆြးေႏြးပြဲအေပၚ သေဘာထားထုတ္ျပန္ခ်က္

By United Nationalities Federal Council


Land and River Grabbing: The Mekong's Greatest Challenge

By Center for ASEAN Studies and The Regional for Social Science and Sustainable Development

Contact Us | Privacy Policy
© Burma Partnership

Visit us at the following social networking sites.       



This message was sent to icfab8888.peacefulway@blogger.com from:

Burma Partnership | info@burmapartnership.org | Burma Partnership | http://www.burmapartnership.org | Muang, Chiang Mai 50300, Thailand

Email Marketing by iContact - Try It Free!

No comments: