International Campaign for Freedom of Aung San Suu Kyi and Burma


Tuesday, May 6, 2014

Weekly Highlights: Will Japan Become a Model of Irresponsible Development in Burma?

 

April 28 - May 4 2014

Weekly Highlights

Will Japan Become a Model of Irresponsible Development in Burma?


As the Thilawa Special Economic Zone Project (Thilawa SEZ) forges ahead, anger over the treatment of the local communities who are being displaced is growing. The Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), who just signed a deal that formalizes the financing of Thilawa SEZ is treating the communities currently living on the site area with undisguised disdain, drawing ire from local and international organizations, including on their home turf.

Covering around 2,400 hectares of land, the Thilawa SEZ is located 20km outside Rangoon and will include factories, a deep sea port, housing developments and other infrastructure for transport and communications. The project is a joint effort between Japan and Burma, with the Burma government and domestic businesses holding a 51% stake and the Japan government and Japanese businesses owning a 49% stake with funding being channelled through JICA as part of Japan's overseas development assistance. Yet in order for these components to go ahead thousands of local people will be displaced. Phase One of the project, which has already started, has seen the relocation of 300 villagers yet the relocation site consists of inadequate housing, no alternative farmland, a lack of a clean water supply and very few livelihood opportunities, leaving people in debt just a few months after moving.

Neither the Burma government, nor JICA are listening to the concerns of these villagers. Despite repeated requests for meetings with JICA, and letters sent to outline their concerns over new living conditions, JICA has absolved itself of responsibility, claiming it is the Burma government's job. Yet this is the same government whom, in August 2013, forced villagers to sign relocation agreements with the threat of destroying their homes, while said villagers were not provided a copy of this agreement.  

As the Japanese NGO, Mekong Watch, pointed out in a statement issued last week, this violates JICA's own social and environmental safeguards, "JICA incorporates stakeholder opinions into decision-making processes regarding environmental and social considerations by ensuring the meaningful participation of stakeholders in order to have consideration for environmental and social factors and to reach a consensus accordingly. JICA replies to stakeholders' questions." If JICA's constant refusal to meet or reply to the letters of affected communities does this mean that the people currently living on this site are not a stakeholder? Meanwhile, JICA's safeguards on resettlement are also being breached. A Resettlement Work Plan does not give a fair price for lost crops and livestock or take the human rights context into consideration.

This is not the only mega project that JICA is involved with in Burma. In October 2013, JICA published a study it conducted in eastern Burma of a framework for development, including industrial estates and free trade zones, urban development of towns, and resettlement sites and economic opportunity for returning refugees and internally-displaced persons (IDPs). What the study assumes is that peace in this area, which has been suffering from the negative effects of armed conflict for decades, will be achieved through development. The worrying part of this framework is that eastern Burma is still a very fragile place, with ceasefires only initial and long-standing issues yet to be addressed. As such, it is an extremely sensitive situation. If JICA plans to bulldoze ahead with projects such as industrial estates and infrastructure, all the while ignoring concerns of local stakeholders just as it has done with Thilawa SEZ, the consequences are potentially hugely destructive and the outbreak of active conflict a very real possibility.

JICA's own guidelines state that relocated people are provided with at least the same livelihood opportunities as before and that they must consult widely with stakeholders. As seen with its framework for the development of eastern Burma, Japan has huge plans, but if Thilawa SEZ is the starting point, it sets a terrible precedent for future projects.

JICA must abide by its own environmental and social safeguards, they are written for a reason. This includes not only consulting with the affected communities, but taking their concerns into account and addressing them. Furthermore, it must provide adequate livelihood opportunities and compensation for those relocated, and with the spiraling debt of those already relocated, this is an urgent matter. Without genuine and transparent dialogue with local communities, as well as ensuring local communities are part of making decisions that will permanently affect their future livelihood, Japan's reputation in Burma will be sullied permanently and Thilawa SEZ, rather than being a showcase of sustainable development and prosperity, will be a symbol of disregard for the rights of local people.

News Highlights

The Karen National Union (KNU)  and the United Wa State Army (UWSA) denounce recent conflict in Kachin State after meeting in UWSA territory
while civilians who have been displaced due to the fighting in Kachin State are now suffering from aid and food shortages and the government has agreed to the Kachin Independence Organization's request to hold talks in Myitkyina

 

Inside Burma

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and 88 Generation Students group join together at rallies in Rangoon and Mandalay calling for amendment of the 2008 Constitution

Armed groups reluctant to stay at the negotiating table with Burma Army due to disagreements over the six point demand, which includes instructions to respect the 2008 Constitution

A new Karen ethnic party The Karen National Party to form

Mizzima journalist charged under Article 18 of the Peaceful Assembly and Peaceful Procession Law for organizing a protest against an arrest of another journalist, while the lawyer for Unity Weekly CEO and journalists objects to court procedure, stating that it is not in conformity with statute law

Only food distribution by the World Food Program has returned to the crisis stricken Arakan State, despite government's pledge to allow NGOs to resume operations and aid agencies must now negotiate with Arakan State Emergency Coordination Centre who will decide how aid is distributed in the area, raising concerns that aid agencies will have to compromise on principles of humanitarian impartiality to resume operations, while a huge conference of Arakanese people concludes with calls to create an Arakan Army to protect themselves against Muslim communities

Regional

China imposes new financial constraints that could deter further investment in the Myitsone Dam project

Thailand's Siam Commercial Bank to extend its services in Burma

International

USPresident Obama warns of the dangers of discrimination and violence against Muslims in Burma during a speech in Malaysia and promptly rejected by Burma President spokesperson

The World Bank warns of high levels of inflation in Burma

Opinion

When Will the World Act on Myanmar's Abuses?

By Emanuel Stoakes
Al-Jazeera

A 'Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement' - For What?
By Bertil Lintner
The Irrawaddy

Latest from the Blog


More Transparency Required Regarding Burma Army's Operations

By Burma Partnership

 

Actions

Villagers near Dawei stage a protest against a planned oil refinery that will ultimately displace two villages, a plan backed by the Chinese, Burma Army, and Burma's crony capitalists

Farmers in Naypyidaw plan a protest to take back their land by ploughing the fields confiscated by the military

Workers rally in Rangoon and Mandalay for more labor rights on May Day

Statements and Press Releases

United Nations Expert Says There are "Elements of Genocide" against Myanmar's Rohingya

By Burmese Rohingya Organisation UK (BROUK) and Ko Maung Zarni  

JICA Continues to Ignore People Affected by Thilawa Special Economic Zone (SEZ) in Burma (Myanmar)
By Mekong Watch

Reports

Deciphering Myanmar's Peace Process - A Reference Guide (2014)

By Burma News International

Contact Us | Privacy Policy
© Burma Partnership

Visit us at the following social networking sites.       

             

 



This message was sent to icfab8888.peacefulway@blogger.com from:

Burma Partnership | http://www.burmapartnership.org | Muang, Chiang Mai 50300, Thailand

Email Marketing by iContact - Try It Free!

Manage Your Subscription  |  Forward This Message

No comments:

As Daw Aung San Suu Kyi proclaimed,

As Daw Aung San Suu Kyi proclaimed,
"Justice is a dream. But it is a dream we are determined to realize."